As promised, I have spent some time comparing the various benefits of PBX-in-a-Flash over trixbox. In a nutshell, my conclusion is relatively straightforward.
Tuesday, March 04, 2008
PBX in a Flash vs. trixbox
Thursday, February 21, 2008
PBX in a Flash
Last week I downloaded and installed the new PBX in a Flash alternative to Trixbox. I have had excellent luck with Trixbox, and no real complaints, but I like to keep abreast of things, had some time on my hand, and thought I'd give it a whirl.
I am impressed.
Monday, December 17, 2007
Trixbox phones home?
Nerdvittles has an interesting post today -- apparently, trixbox phones home at 3:41 AM each day and gets a list of shell commands to run:
You may have read that a user discovered last week that current trixbox systems as recently as today include a remotely-configurable BOT, a software program that can execute certain commands locally once it receives its instructions. Reportedly, trixbox’s registry.pl “phones home” to Fonality via the Internet at 3:41 a.m. each morning to get a list of Linux commands to run. It then executes those Linux commands on your server while you’re sleeping. If the assertions of trixbox end users are true and we have no reason to believe otherwise, the existence of this remotely-configurable BOT had never been disclosed to unsuspecting users whether they were individuals or corporations. In fact, it doesn’t appear that even trixbox resellers were aware of the existence of the remotely-configurable BOT.This is interesting, and disturbing. To be fair, the folks at Nerdvittles suggest that they "don’t for a minute believe that Chris Lyman and other senior management of Fonality knew about this in advance", but they certainly know about it now!
This is cause for concern. Since the ability to remotely execute shell commands exists, it's only a matter of time before someone else figures out how to exploit it.
Maybe it's time to accelerate my testing of pbx-in-a-flash....
Monday, November 12, 2007
Use the Linksys SPA922 as a Remote Extension
Last time I mentioned that I had used the Linksys SPA922 IP Phone as the "handset of choice" for phones. I also indicated that I wanted to have one as a remote extension -- i.e., it has a standard extension number, is part of the PBX system, can make and receive calls, etc., but is physically outside of the network.

extern_ip=xxx.xxx.xxx.xxxlocalnet=192.168.0.0/255.255.255.0
We need to make some modifications on the Trixbox end of the network (i.e. not at home, if that's where your remote extension is, but on the the end of the connection where your Trixbox PBX lives). Specific modifications will vary depending on what you are using for a router/gateway, but in general there are only a few things to change. I am using a Linksys machine as the external gateway, so I made changes as follows:

In essence, forward the following to your Trixbox machine:
5004-5082 udp
16384-16482 udp
10001 - 20001 udp
4569 udp (optional, and only for IAX2 units; ignore if you are just using sip)
Make these changes, and we are ready to set up the phone itself.
Configure the SPA922 IP Phone
All configuration on the SPA922 can be done with a web browser... but you need to know what IP address to connect to. After it has powered up, click on the "menu" button on the handset. It looks like a dog-eared piece of paper, just below the voice mail button. Now use the navigation button (big circle with four arrows) to scroll down to Network, and click the select soft button (leftmost, just below the LCD. Its label is part of the LCD). You'll see your phone's IP address displayed on the LCD. Mine was set to 192.168.2.149.
So, fire up your web browser, and go to http://192.168.2.149, or whatever IP address your phone has. You'll see the Linksys screen. Click on "Admin Login" in the upper right hand corner, then "Advanced." Note that by default the phone ships with no password for the admin tool; please remember to change that at some point (like right now).
Click on the Ext1 tab, and scroll down to NAT Settings. Set NAT Mapping Enable and NAT Keepalive Enable to "YES". Scroll down to SIP Settings. Set SIP Port and Ext SIP port both to 5062.
Next scroll down to the "Proxy and Registration" section. Set "Proxy" and "Outbound Proxy" to the external IP address used by your Trixbox machine. Set "Use Outbound Proxy" and "Use OB in Dialog" to "Yes".
Scroll down to Subscriber information, and set User ID to the extension number for your phone, and password to whatever "secret" you set up in Trixbox for this extension.
Now scroll down to Audio Configuration. Set DTMF Tx Method to "Inband+INFO". (Note: I had to do this to get most IVRs to work, i.e. when I call someone and have to press 1 for this, 2 for that, and so forth. YMMV).
Click on "Submit all Changes."
Now, go to the SIP tab. Scroll down to RTP Parameters. Set RTP port min to 16384. Set RTP port max to 16482. Now, scroll down to NAT Support Parameters. Set Handle VIA received, Insert VIA received, Substitute VIA address, Handle VIA rport, and Insert VIA rport all to "Yes."
Save your changes, and in a few moments, you should be able to make calls!
Sunday, October 21, 2007
Alternative to Trixbox coming soon
The folks over at nerdvittles.com have an interesting project in the works -- PBX in a Flash. Apparently they (and others) are getting a bit fed up with the direction that Trixbox is taking; on the nerdvittles site, the authors put it this way: "suffice it to say that it’s just gotten a little too proprietary, too closed, and too commercial for our open source, puritanical tastes."
So they decided to take matters into their own hands, and are working on something called "PBX in a Flash". From the site:
Our up front promise is to keep the project open, participatory, reliable, and fun. After all, that’s what the Asterisk revolution was and is all about. The plan is to provide a free ISO-based offering for home or office use that will run on a dedicated Linux machine. There also will be a VMware image that will run on a Windows desktop. And, for the Mac desktop, we’ll provide both a VMware and a Parallels image.
I'll be interested to see where this goes, and intend to give it a try.
Friday, November 24, 2006
Replace your phone service with Skype
The folks over at Linuxjournal.com have a nifty how-to guide for replacing your PSTN phone service (that's Public Switched Telephone Network, for people like me, who are still new to this whole VOIP thing) with a Skype based solution.
This is rather slick...
The author claims that his "solution was to build a Skype server that provides 24/7 phone service with the minimum of hassle and fuss. By dumping your regular phone company and taking back control of your home phone wiring using a Skype server, you will have not only a phone system with nearly the same capabilities as before-indeed, in some ways better-you will also save a bundle of money! In my case, I save a little less than $700 US each year (this year, next year, and the year after that, and so on), or about 82% off of my old phone bill."
Hmmm... 82% is a lot of dough.
Update:
Darn. The SkypeIn service (details on the Skype website) is not yet available in Canada. Well, it is, but my next door neighbours would have to call a number in some other country to get me... and that's not going to happen.
Oh well.
Tuesday, November 21, 2006
Interesting Add On for Asterisk
While planning for my Asterisk install, it occurred to me that someone has almost certainly already built and released an open source project for web based administration of the server. While I have by no means completed my research into this topic, I did stumble across a very nice package called VoiceOne. This seems to be almost exactly what I will need.
Here is a sample screenshot of the application. It looks very promising.
Asterisk update
I've been doing some more reading about the hardware requirements and options for setting up an Asterisk PBX, and came across this information:
"If you build an Asterisk system without the need for PCI cards, you have a much greater set of choices for what kind of computer to run Asterisk on. If things are configured correctly, the ATAs are handling all of the load for coding/decoding digitized streams of voice to/from analog. You have a better chance of being able to successfully share a computer for asterisk and some other tasks. There are some great choices in small form factor computers. It's even possible to run Asterisk on a Linksys WRT54GS, but that box is a bit too underpowered for a full featured Asterisk configuration. Linksys also sells ATAs with firmware from Sipura. Now it's been announced that Linksys is buying Sipura. I haven't seen any reports on hacking the version of the WRT54G with the embedded ATA yet, but I'm hoping we might see some pretty cool things soon."
Please note that I fixed some spelling errors in this prior to putting it here. I can't help it; the English prof in me takes precedence over the nerd from time to time. Anyway, it sounds a lot like the external box (i.e. the Linksys - Sipura SPA-3000) might be a better solution given that I'm using older hardware for my home installation of Asterisk. After a bit of browsing, I found an excellent price on one here, in Canada. I'm tempted to try this using my Linksys WRT54GS router, but since that's currently connecting my antenna to the Internet, I might be asking it to do more than it can.
Monday, November 20, 2006
Planning the Asterisk Install
After reviewing the basic instructions found here, it would appear that I need to purchase PCI cards with Foreign eXchange Station (FXS) ports, and with Foreign Exchange Office ports. Telephones are connected to the FXS ports, and phone lines are connected to the FXO ports.
Apparently bad things happen if you get this wrong. FXS ports provide power and generate ring signals, while FXO ports receive power and ring signals. I'll have to be careful with that.
I'm also going to need an Analog Telephone Adaptor, or ATA, that acts as a gateway between my digital network (the Asterisk box) and plain old analog phones and phone lines. Fortunately, the most common ATAs offer FXS ports, so there is less hardware to buy (and money to spend).
Apparently there has been considerable success using the TDM400P with a couple of daughter cards for a self contained PC to handle everything. Or, we could go with the Sipura 3000 (a stand alone box that you connect your Asterisk machine to via ethernet). I guess it all comes down to price.
Pricing out the first option, the Digium TDM400P, doesn't look too bad. I found a decent price here, at voipdepot.ca.
My, what a wonderful new crop of acronyms to learn. I connect from the CO to my FXO, then go through my ATA to FXS to connect to a phone and get dial tone. What fun.
Sunday, November 19, 2006
Why install Asterisk at home?
I've had a number of people ask me why I would be interested in installing Asterisk PBX at home. Well, there are a number of reasons. First, I pay for voice mail and a few other features on my home phones, and it costs me a bit of cash every month. The PBX will pay for itself inside of a year. The main reason, though, is functionality. Here are some of the features that are of interest to me:
- Sophisticated Voice Mail system - This can provide a mail box per person, that can be deliver notification by e-mail. Web based access to your voice mail is also available.
- Interactive Voice Response IVR system - You can present callers with a menu, which can be particularly useful if you have more people in the house than you have incoming phone lines. "Press 1 for Him, Press 2 for Her, Press 3 for Kid No. 1, Press 4 for Kid No. 2"...
- Control over which phones ring, and at what times.
- Functions as an Intercom - Place in house calls.
- Call routing - Route incoming calls by Caller ID.
- Multi-line functionality - if you need more than 2 incoming lines, you will quickly discover that phones that handle more than two lines are much more expensive than 1 or 2 line phones, and there isn't very much selection available.
- Call Detail Reports - for attempting to gain some control over costs, and/or teenagers, etc.
- Check your voice mail over the web.
- Email notification of voice mail.
Plus, it's cool. And although I do hate to admit it, there is a fairly wide "geek" streak in me. It rears its ugly head sometimes.
Saturday, November 18, 2006
Progress with Asterisk

I've made some progress with my Asterisk PBX planning. As I indicated earlier, I had to do a re-install of the operating system on my backup server (From FreeBSD to CentOS) first, and I've managed to get that out of the way. I've also developed a strong appreciation and respect for the "yum" package manager. It's very good, and as easy to use as ports on FreeBSD.
Anyway, I've begun the work necessary to build a simple PBX system at home, using Asterisk. I figure I'll practice at home, and if it works well, eventually migrate my business onto the same system. At this point, it's largely reading and research, as I have to (gasp) actually purchase some hardware in order to make this work.
Apparently, I'm going to need a PSTN interface card.
For those not in the know (like me, up until recently), PSTN stands for Public Switched Telephone Network. Also, POTS is Plain Old Telephone Service. And in case you were wondering, PBX stands for Private Branch eXchange. Wikipedia has some great info on the history of the PBX.
I'm sorry for the digression.
A PSTN interface card is the basic device that permits you to connect analog or digital phone lines (the ones that you use at work or at home to connect regular phones to) to your PBX. Once you've done that you have access to all the nifty features that Asterisk offers, such as call parking, voice mail, and so forth.
There is a helpful site found here that details all of the various cards known to work well with Asterisk. I'm going to have to do some serious price comparison for awhile, and find one known to work well with my system.
This is going to take awhile.
Thursday, November 16, 2006
Asterisk - VOIP for the handyman
While configuring my backup server, it occurred to me that this would be an ideal time to try working with Asterisk, the free VOIP solution available for Linux. Naturally, this entails re-doing much of what I have already done with Samba, as I chose FreeBSD as my operating system. I'll have to strip it and go with CentOS instead. Sigh.
The Asterisk site claims that Asterisk is a complete PBX in software. It runs on Linux, BSD and MacOSX and provides all of the features you would expect from a PBX and more. Asterisk does voice over IP in many protocols, and can interoperate with almost all standards-based telephony equipment using relatively inexpensive hardware. However, my research has indicated that it runs best on Linux, so Linux it is.
I'll keep you posted. And this time I'll take notes.